Ain't that ....

20th Century FoxHas this happened to you?

At knoxnews, we post a lot of our videos on YouTube, especially those done by our TV critic (they get a lot more traffic there than on our site).

However, we recently received this email from YouTube.

Dear Member:

This is to notify you that we have removed or disabled access to the following material as a result of a third-party notification by Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation claiming that this material is infringing:

"Reno 911!" officers "ain't retarded": http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xl4V4lzTyI8

Ok, this is a video that our writer shot. It wasn't shot on a movie or TV set. It's not a bootleg movie or even a movie trailer. It's journalism; it's an interview!

Here's the offending clip in Windows Media (WMV) format.

What's up with that?

It makes me think that the garish cigar-chomping studio bosses of yore would like come back as the studio bosses of the Internet. But the studio system ended sometime back in the 20th century, right? Maybe not at 20th Century Fox.

Now, that's retarded.

Related Entries

5 Comments

Yeah, that was like boneheaded.

You know, you can send a reply to YouTube and whoever sent the takedown notice could be punished for sending frivolous takedown requests. That's in the DMCA, and a couple of people are already pursuing Viacom because of that type of heavy-handed b.s.

"Has this happened to you?"

Yes, it HAS happened to me! I'm the guy that SayUncle above cited.

I got the clip of VH1 using my video restored to YouTube. The Electronic Frontier Foundation ( http://www.eff.org is their website) was a huge help. The most important thing that I did was file a DMCA counter-notification claim. I posted how I did that on my blog at http://theknightshift.blogspot.com/2007/09/youtubeviacom-aftermath-part-2-dmca.html

You guys should seriously fight this! Y'all have an even stronger case than I did IMHO.

Good luck!
Chris Knight
theknightshift.blogspot.com

Leave a comment

Recent Entries

  • DIY blueprint: Creating a media venture in a weekend

    Great behind-the-scenes piece from search engine expert Danny Sullivan on the launch of laid-off newspaperman Greg Hernandez's Greg in Hollywood blog.Basically a tool-kit for doing...

  • Carl Malamud for Public Printer of the U.S.

    I can't think of anyone more qualified in the Digital Age to be the government's head printer than Carl Malamud.Find out about his campaign to...

  • Journalism is not a federal earmark

    Dave Winer, a guy who loves news and, who among his many pioneering achievements, put the New York Times into RSS, says the newsroom curmudgeons...

  • Records behind bars

    SPJ has joined an open records battle in Tennessee. INDIANAPOLIS - The Society of Professional Journalists has joined an amicus brief written by the Tennessee...

  • Reading is fundamental

    Read The Bill from Sunlight Foundation on Vimeo.It's not a novel, but it would be novel to read legislation before it's voted on. There's...

Activity Stream

  • Jack D. Lail tweeted, "[ Reader] Would You Pay to Read This Story? - The Daily Beast: Shared by jack Yet another take on pay m.. http://tinyurl.com/df9jzo"
  • Jack D. Lail shared Would You Pay to Read This Story? - The Daily Beast from www.thedailybeast.com
  • Jack D. Lail tweeted, "@RobRichards I caught up with the Daily Show piece on CNBC. He nailed them. They are parodies of themselves."
  • Jack D. Lail tweeted, "CNBC seems reactionary shrill. Declares stimulus a bust. It's barely started. Did somebody sit on their bonus?"
  • Jack D. Lail tweeted, "Houston and San Antonio newspapers might merge? http://tinyurl.com/addrnc (via @FrankStrovel)"
More ...
Close